Electric car owners should be able to choose the noise that their car makes

What noise would you choose?

Electric Golf GTI being charged

One of the supposed benefits of electric vehicles (EVs) is the lack of noise pollution that they produce, but that could be about to change drastically under new UK, European and US regulations stating that silently-driven vehicles must be fitted with an Acoustic Vehicle Alert System (AVAS) so pedestrians can hear them approaching.

The noises are currently decided by car manufacturers, but the US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration said that they believe car owners should be able to customise their vehicles to play ‘the sound they prefer from a set of sounds installed in the vehicle’.

The claims have started something of a social media frenzy, with users providing their own suggestions for noises that they’d like to hear on the road – including ‘a stampede of bisons’, ‘blowing a raspberry’ and Rick Astley’s 1980s hit single ‘Never Gonna Give You Up’.

Read more: Motorists are less stressed and more calm when driving electric cars - a study

Electric cars ‘pose a danger to vulnerable road users’

Vehicle safety campaigner, Chris Hanson-Abbott, insists that ‘the fact there is no requirement to fit any system means there are hundreds and thousands of electric and quiet vehicles on Britain’s roads which pose a danger to vulnerable road users.’

Guide Dogs for the Blind are one of several charities that have expressed further concerns surrounding the use of electric vehicles, stating that they are 40% more likely to be involved in an accident with a pedestrian than a normal car.

It is for this reason that AVAS electric car devices were initially introduced, with the UK government stating that they ‘want the benefits of green transport to be felt by everyone, and understands the concerns of the visually impaired about the possible hazards posed by quiet electric vehicles.’

There are more than 200,000 electric vehicles already in use that are not legally required to have any warning sounds, with the law for all-electric vehicles being fitted with AVAS devices not coming into play until 2021 – newly manufactured vehicles have been fitted with the devices since 1 July 2019.

As it stands, the noise devices fitted to electric vehicles will simply mimic the noise made by a traditional engine, while some manufacturers have developed specific sound palettes to help vulnerable road users to identify potential dangers.

Jaguar I-Pace electric cars, for example, are fitted with a sound that is easily heard by trained guide dogs, while electric Mercedes-Benz vehicles are fitted with an artificial humming sound.

Most of these come at no extra cost, however some luxury manufacturers like Porsche charge around £354 to drivers who want to fit their car with an ‘Electric Sport Sound’.

Read more: Everything you need to know about electric car insurance

Choosing your own engine noise – V8 turbo or Jetsons spaceship?

With electric vehicles becoming more and more popular, what we want to know is, what noise would you choose for your car to make when out on the road?

Here are some of the inspired responses on social media that have caught our eye (but may not be to everyone's taste!):

Twitter post saying that the Crazy Frog song should be an option

Don't be surprised if this engine sound results in your car getting toad.

A twitter post saying that there should be an Italian V12 electric car sound

An excellent sound, for sure, but not quite so convincing coming from a family saloon!

A twitter post stating that the Star Wars theme tune should be available with electric cars

This would instantly make your car the most powerful one on the road.

A twitter post saying that electric car users should be able to select their own music to have internally and externally

Because keeping your favourite music all to yourself would be selfish…

So, what we want to know is, what sound would you choose to replace a traditional engine noise? Perhaps a cockerel to wake you (and everybody else) up in the morning? Or maybe some soothing ocean noises to start your day off right.

You can let us know by heading over to Bobatoo’s Facebook page here!

Related articles:

The most popular electric cars in the UK revealed

New battery technology could make electric vehicles cheaper

Nearly half of UK drivers say they can’t afford to buy an electric car